Every startup founder thinks they have a clear, compelling story.
However, most positioning falls flat outside the founder’s head. What makes perfect sense to you often lands as vague, confusing, or indistinguishable to your customers.
Strong positioning is about clarity, resonance, and proof. And the only way to know if your message is working is to test it.
In this guide, we’ll walk through five practical ways to validate your positioning and messaging, from quick litmus tests to deeper customer research.
By the end, you’ll know whether your story is landing, or whether it’s time to sharpen, iterate, or overhaul it.
Bad positioning is expensive. It drives up customer acquisition costs, slows sales cycles, and forces you to rely on discounts or persuasion to get deals over the line.
Good positioning does the opposite by helping people instantly understand why you matter and why you’re different.
“Customers need to quickly understand what you are, why they should care, and why you are different from the alternatives.” - April Dunford, author of Obviously Awesome
If you can’t answer those questions in the language your customers understand, your startup will struggle to grow.
You can’t just believe your positioning works; you need evidence.
Start with the basics. If your positioning is clear, you should be able to answer these five questions in one or two sentences each:
If you stumble or drift into jargon, your positioning isn’t ready.
Try running this exercise with your leadership team and your sales or customer-facing staff.
If everyone gives wildly different answers, that’s a red flag. You need internal alignment before you can achieve clarity outside..
This is the simplest and most brutal test you can do.
Take your homepage, pitch deck, or one-liner and put it in front of someone who knows nothing about your business. Give them 30 seconds to read or listen. Then ask:
If they can’t answer accurately, your message isn’t working.
A Nielsen Norman Group study found that users often leave webpages within 10–20 seconds if they don’t find a clear value proposition. That’s how little time you really have.
If a stranger can’t get it in 30 seconds, your prospects won’t either.
Customer interviews are one of the fastest ways to test your positioning.
Listen for how they naturally describe your product, problem, or value.
Slack famously found traction when it shifted from ‘a tool for teams’ to ‘be less busy’.
This was a phrase that echoed how users described its value.
Use feedback to refine your messaging in the same language your audience already trusts.
Your sales and support teams are on the frontlines. If positioning isn’t working, they’ll know first.
Ask them:
HubSpot, for example, constantly iterates its messaging based on feedback loops from its sales reps. The result is positioning that matches real conversations, not just marketing theory.
Qualitative feedback is powerful, but you also need quantitative signals. Use your digital touchpoints as a lab:
For example, if a landing page with ‘Save time and money’ outperforms one with ‘Streamline collaboration,’ that’s data on what resonates most with your audience.
Not every messaging tweak requires a total reset. Use this rule of thumb:
Think of positioning as a living system, not a one-time project.
Markets shift, competitors emerge, and customer needs evolve. If you’re not reviewing and testing regularly, you risk slipping into irrelevance.
Clear messaging drives growth; unclear messaging hinders it.
Test fast, listen to customers, and use data to decide whether to tweak or reset. The sooner you validate your story, the sooner others will believe it.
Vestd specialises in employee share schemes that align founders, leaders, and teams for the long run. Find out more here.